Progressives Have a Hashtag

It sounds to me like it should be the name of a third-party candidate in that Kodos and Kang election episode of The Simpsons, but "topprog" is actually a new political Twitter hashtag that is starting to find traction. I've been beating the drum for a short while now on the fact that conservatives are organizing better and faster than the left on Twitter, as evidenced by Top Conservatives on Twitter/#tcot -- which is, of course, the model for this "Top Progressives" project. (For what it's worth, one prominent conservative I spoke with recently pronounced it "tee-cot." Now you know.)

The #topprog hashtag was proposed in an email from Alan Rosenblatt, the associate director of online advocacy at the Center for American Progress Action Fund:

Help Organize Progressives on Twitter!

So the conservative tweeters are organizing on Twitter, using #tcot as their hash tag whenever they post. They have a website as well: http://www.topconservativesontwitter.org/.

In an effort to counter organize, let's start using #topprog as our progressive hash tag on Twitter.

A component of the Top Conservatives on Twitter project is a leader board of, well, the conservatives who have been deemed tops on Twitter. (My understanding is that while the board was once derived by hand, there's now some sort of fancy algorithm that determines the rankings.) Rosenblatt reports that a leader board for the left is in the works. This being progressives, there's been some push back on the the elitism and exclusion that might be implied by that approach. Take this from one @anotherpundit:

top conservatives on twitter is hat tip to elite frame - only elite can govern, have opinion. #topprog reinforces... no?

No matter. The #topprog hashtag has had pretty good pick-up today, as you can see for yourself. It hasn't, though, topped the Twitter Trending Topics list in the way that, say, Snuggies have. But really, it's a bit much to ask discussions of political ideology to compete with blankets with arms.

Jon Pincus has some additional thoughts on #topprog, including on how the hashtag could the gender imbalance you might see on a site like Digg.

Categories: 

Comments

It's potentially non-elitist ...

A lot depends on how much revolves around the "leaderboard" -- and what metrics are tracked. And the open and inclusive nature of hashtags mitigates some of the mechanisms by which elitism reinforces its power (secret members-only groups for example), but there's only so much you can do: somebody with thousands of followers is typically going to have more influence than somebody with only a few. Still in the aggregate I think the potential's there for it to work out very well. Stefan Deeran has a good post on this in Exception Magazine, with quotes from Alan as well as Michael Leahy, the Republican strategist behind #tcot. jon -- http://talesfromthe.net/jon

#TPOT

Using #TPOT (pr. Tea-pot) instead would have saved three characters. Never know when they might come in handy. ;-)

Twitter is an awful organizing medium

Seriously, it's been around for over two years, and the only example of semi-effective political organizing done on Twitter was the "Let Our Congress Tweet" initiative, which was probably only successful thanks to its navel-gazing qualities. One-hundred forty characters at a time is simply too limiting, and Twitter's collective attention span is worse than that of my twelve week old puppy's. Twitter is for procrastination, not for activism. As a partisan Democrat, I hope to see #TCOT continue, only because that means Republicans continue to waste their time on Twitter rather than effectively organizing via more productive avenues.

Leftmost Bit

You're missing a lot of effective organizing.

Andreas Jungherr's Uses of Twitter for Political Activism is a good overview. Three recent examples from the US: #dontgo, Twitter Vote Report, and the Motrin Moms. Sure there are challenges for using Twitter, and there's some things that it's just not good for. But writing it off and conceding it to conservatives is short-sighted. jon -- http://talesfromthe.net/jon