Report from Chicago: "We're Making This Up As We Go Along"

Some information is starting to filter out of this past weekend's "summit" in Chicago of about 300 key organizers from Barack Obama's 2008 campaign (evenly divided between regional field directors, field organizers, and team leaders). Tony Loyd, an organizer from Racine, Wisconsin, reports on the YesWeCanRacine website back to the members of his local group:

Here are the outcomes of the meeting.

1. There is a process that is still forming, based on your input. Let’s be honest: we’re making this up as we go along. We want to take the time to get this right.
2. The process has been and will continue to be open and transparent. We’re trying to make sure you hear about this from us instead of read about it in the press, though I understand that word is already starting to leak out.
3. The first step was to gain feedback from the field about what you want from this organization. We have already heard back from over 500,000 people. The first steps of forming this organization are being strongly influenced by the survey results.
4. Please be patient. You may have heard the president say that he is going to move with “deliberate haste” in the transition. In the same way, we’re moving with deliberate haste in forming the new organization.

Our goals will be as follows:

1. Legislative Priorities – We will use the organizing principles of the campaign to rally support for the legislative agenda. Though we do not yet have a legislative calendar, count on an economic stimulus package in early January and be ready to take massive action in support of that priority. Expect similar action on health care, energy and the environment to follow. I’m sure we will hear more about the priorities in coming days.
2. Electoral Organizing – Let’s use the organizing model to rally behind and support candidates. Perhaps you will want to consider running for office yourself. Or perhaps we can find someone else who shares our values and put them forth.
3. Civic Engagement – During the election we tapped into a deep well of volunteerism that can be applied to local issues from hunger and homelessness to education and the environment. For example, there are homeless families here in Racine County who need our help.
4. Promote two-way Conversation – It’s important to realize that this is not a monologue but a dialog. The campaign is sincerely interested in your input. We spent a majority of time at the conference looking backwards at what we did right and what could have been done better. Jon Carson was present for all of these conversations. He and the leadership team want your input.

A few observations on what is obviously still a work in progress:
1. Yes, information will leak. If people haven't noticed, the internet views suppression of information as damage and routes around it.
2. 500,000 responses to the online survey asking for feedback on planning is low from the perspective of having 13 million email addresses (a response rate of 10% is a reasonable target), but on the other hand, half a million people expressing continued interest in being involved in any kind of Obama-style organization is pretty huge.
3. Not surprisingly, Chicago is planning to use this network to mobilize support for Obama's legislative agenda.
4. Interestingly, they're also talking about electoral organizing in support of candidates for office. This will be VERY interesting.
5. It's great that Chicago is looking for more input and that this is seen as a "dialog," not a monologue. However, they have a long way to go before we can fairly call this a two-way conversation.

To be continued, hopefully...

0
Your rating: None

Comments

comments on "Report from Chicago"

I'm surprised by how closely this report mirrors my own thoughts and questions following Nov 4. The "goals" you reported were exactly what I've boiled things down to while planning for the "Change is Coming" meeting this weekend. By all accounts this has been a stellar campaign (the best ever?)and by my own account a life changing 20 months of work. I'm honored and thankful to have been part of it. So the following may seem sort of sour... but the only kind of organizing I want to be a part of IS bottom-up. That's why I got involved. And it NEEDS to become a dialog, or the fundamental change we have worked for will not, in the end, be realized. Under "observations" the most interesting point to me was #5. I was a Colorado county coordinator in Aug 07, when we had only one paid Obama staff member. As things heated up I focused on my house district, and continued as the hub for our grass roots organization through Nov 4, when I was one of two staging location directors. Between Dec 07, when all of our staff were (wisely) sent to Iowa, and Nov 08, the campaign began to seem(to me)less bottom up. The sense I had between June and Nov 07 was that the field staff believed they were here to organize volunteers. We were already well-organized. Now, having heard nothing from field staff since Nov 4, my hunch is that either 1.)my corner of CO is now off the radar (understandably), or 2.) at least from the point of view of field staff, both information and directives flow DOWN from Chicago, through them (the field staff), to us (the volunteers), if they think it's important to keep us in the loop. It doesn't need to be said, but I'm going to say it anyway: we volunteers worked our butts off over a very long period of time for no pay. To be fair, I've been complicit in this; I make a point of not "bugging" higher-ups unless something truly urgent comes up, and since Nov 4 I've been laying VERY low. I have not sought any contact. But maybe it's time for folks like me to raise our voices. KHahn

Bottom Up Rules to Remember:

What Interested me from the news we are getting within the MyBO groups, with regards to both the Chicago and Harvard Meetings on the future of the Obama Movement is that the grassroots were left out as if to marginalize the true strength of the Obama Campaign. From the trenches, my sense is that 2 million Obamerican Campaign Volunteers are standing still, with our motors ideling. This current standstill condition will not last. No Countywide or "Local Set of MyBO Groups" need Washington or Chicago to tell us what to do, or who to support. We have corruption throughout all levels of government as well. Chicago does not have a monopoly on operating a grease pit. In San Francisco, our past Mayor Willy Brown stated "it's not what you do, it's whether you get caught!". This Attitude and Mindset is what the grassroots will change from Local Governments, thru to our State Governments, and to Our Federal Government. Change will come from the bottom - and the Community Action Networks will not stand still, waiting, motors running. Local Communities do not need to be told what to do - rather Government needs to listen. Throughout the last election phase - the grassroots were always out in front. I don't expect Government will change unless pushed - hard! This will happen. But the "Roar" heard around the world on November 4th 2008 is only an opener! We want change. We will work hard to bring change. All politicians who don't get it, may need an education from the grassroots. It's not a New Deal - Its a New ERA! Katherine should look to the ranks. We seemed to all lay low since November 4. No longer. If not now - when? If not us - who? The grassroots have a deep sense of urgency. It's the Party's and their Leaderships, which takes the People for granted. I see and hear thousands of Citizens already stirring - restless - ready in a moments notice to fire it up and move. That old axiom always holds true: You can lead, follow, or get out of the way. We have a deep love and respect of Barack Obama. I believe the media and politicians do not yet understand that We Will Change. Applied to politics: You Can Not Change and Remain The Same. I don't believe the grassroots will wait to begin to recruit and organize 3,260 Counties, and all 50 States. Paul Currier Internet Community Organizer: CAN (Community Action Network) San Francisco, California http://My.BarackObama.com/page/community/blog/PaulCurrier

Bottom Up Rules to Remember:

What Interested me from the news we are getting within the MyBO groups, with regards to both the Chicago and Harvard Meetings on the future of the Obama Movement is that the grassroots were left out as if to marginalize the true strength of the Obama Campaign. From the trenches, my sense is that 2 million Obamerican Campaign Volunteers are standing still, with our motors ideling. This current standstill condition will not last. No Countywide or "Local Set of MyBO Groups" need Washington or Chicago to tell us what to do, or who to support. We have corruption throughout all levels of government as well. Chicago does not have a monopoly on operating a grease pit. In San Francisco, our past Mayor Willy Brown stated "it's not what you do, it's whether you get caught!". This Attitude and Mindset is what the grassroots will change from Local Governments, thru to our State Governments, and to Our Federal Government. Change will come from the bottom - and the Community Action Networks will not stand still, waiting, motors running. Local Communities do not need to be told what to do - rather Government needs to listen. Throughout the last election phase - the grassroots were always out in front. I don't expect Government will change unless pushed - hard! This will happen. But the "Roar" heard around the world on November 4th 2008 is only an opener! We want change. We will work hard to bring change. All politicians who don't get it, may need an education from the grassroots. It's not a New Deal - Its a New ERA! Katherine should look to the ranks. We seemed to all lay low since November 4. No longer. If not now - when? If not us - who? The grassroots have a deep sense of urgency. It's the Party's and their Leaderships, which takes the People for granted. I see and hear thousands of Citizens already stirring - restless - ready in a moments notice to fire it up and move. That old axiom always holds true: You can lead, follow, or get out of the way. We have a deep love and respect of Barack Obama. I believe the media and politicians do not yet understand that We Will Change. Applied to politics: You Can Not Change and Remain The Same. I don't believe the grassroots will wait to begin to recruit and organize 3,260 Counties, and all 50 States. Paul Currier Internet Community Organizer: CAN (Community Action Network) San Francisco, California http://My.BarackObama.com/page/community/blog/PaulCurrier

10% response rate?

Micah, this is some good intel and a fascinating addition to what we know about what might happen with OFA2, but i'm not quite sure where you get the estimate that a 10% response rate is a reasonable target for an online survey. If I recall correctly, the obama online survey required a fairly heavy lift (it was four dense pages) and in my experience, albeit none with lists of that size or attentiveness, a 10% participation rate is about the max rate that one can hope to get for a great petition, much less a survey. In my consulting days I would typically advise clients to expect a 1-3% response rate to a survey, which this number is well within. On a broader note, which you acknowledge, having 500,000 people fill out an online survey about the direction of an organization is simply astounding and is probably close to an order of magnitude larger than any other organization could get for a survey of that level of detail.