Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

Putin Expels USAID; Organization Contributed to Russian NGO that Mapped Electoral Balloting Irregularities

BY Natalia Antonova | Friday, October 5 2012

Screenshot from the Golos election mapping site

Though often derided by critics for underhanded tactics, the Russian government is being upfront this time around. When it came to booting out USAID from the country starting from October 1 of this year, the reasons stated were explicit — i.e., meddling in domestic affairs.

As Russia’s Foreign Ministry put it with regard to USAID’s activities in Russia: “What we are talking about is an attempt to influence political processes — including various elections and social institutions — via the distribution of grants.”

Of particular interest to the authorities was USAID’s funding of election watchdog Golos — that would be the same monitoring organization that helped identify voting irregularities during the State Duma elections in December 2011. And it was after that particular election that, of course, Russia saw its biggest protests since the early 1990’s.

Golos became widely known for an online interactive project called Karta Narusheny — literally, A Map of Election Fraud. The map provided both up-to-date information on any new reported violations as well as statistics.

Golos’s data collection methodology is as follows: Volunteers in the field monitor polling booths in about half of Russia’s vast; and any concerned citizen can upload information about violations to the Golos site, where there are explicit instructions on how to lodge a formal complaint with the authorities. Volunteers provide Golos with updates regarding or not there has been an official response to the complaints.

In the run-up to the regional elections that will take place on October 14, the map is already recording new reports of violations — as of press time, the latest report concerns election posters in the Krasnodar region, where, allegedly, election posters for a United Russia candidate are not being marked correctly, obscuring the fact that the candidate is a member of the ruling party.

It was reports of mass voter fraud on December 4, 2011, that galvanized Russia’s divided protest movement — and swelled its ranks.

Although the country’s ruling United Russia party boasts many gifted, democratically minded members, it is no secret that for local party bosses and election officials, getting the “right” results in an election cycle is essential. The “right” results are a demonstration of political loyalty, which is an essential component of how election politics operate on the lower rungs of the political food chain in Russia. Sometimes it is not even a matter of whether or not the “right” candidate wins — but a matter of by what margin. Results that are too close for comfort, for example, may make one’s party bosses uncomfortable.

For a figure like Vladimir Putin, who, despite seeing his overall popularity rankings decline recently, remains Russia’s most popular politician, winning the recent presidential election was essentially a walk in the park. But for other government representatives, genuine competition in an election cycle may, occasionally, present itself. And competition is still anathema to people who grew up in the Soviet era — when no one had to worry about things like public dissidents or scandals around ballot stuffing.

The casual, low-key voter fraud in Russia is, in that sense, an expression of a kind of nostalgia for the good old days, when there was just one party, and no one worried overmuch about politics — seeing as everything was decided for them. It’s just that nowadays, the Internet gets in the way of all of that, with tech-savvy organizations like Golos attempting to drag election officials kicking and screaming into the modern age.

At the beginning of 2012, Russia surpassed Germany's number of total Internet users — making it the country with the highest number of Internet users in Europe. This may spell trouble down the road for Russia’s state television networks – which have faced criticism for being staunchly pro-Kremlin (though it must be noted that as the protest movement gained momentum recently, key opposition figures suddenly received more air-time — because not even state TV could ignore them, particularly in the regions far from the capital).

But active on the Internet does not necessarily mean politically active. As Alexei Navalny, probably Russia’s most recognizable opposition figure nowadays, put it on his blog: “Look, there are over 70 million people who are online in Russia. But that doesn’t mean that they exist in the same information environment as [the opposition]. The overwhelming majority of these people occasionally use the [Russian social networks] Odnoklassniki [and] Vkontakte, they check the weather, and so on.”

Navalny’s solution to what he sees as the problem of ignorance and complacency among Russian Internet users was to launch a project he calls The Good Propaganda Machine – aimed at getting the oppositions message out to people who otherwise would not hear about it. This includes spreading the news about, say, corruption scandals and controversial court rulings.

Navalny currently faces 10 years’ imprisonment on charges of embezzlement. The criminal case is widely perceived as political in nature.

The fact that Navalny felt he had to include the word “propaganda” in his project shows that public politics in Russia still have a way to go — because, no matter how you cut it, “propaganda” implies brainwashing. If the state brainwashes the population through state TV, the opposition reasons that it can do the same through the Internet. It certainly makes Russia’s political future seem interesting — though one can’t help but wonder when politics in Russia will become more nuanced.

The upcoming October 14 election cycle does not promise much in the way of nuance. The battle lines have been drawn in the sand — and Golos, for one, is expecting more election fraud. The organization will continue its work despite the departure of USAID.

I spoke at length with Grigory Melkonyants, deputy director of Golos, about USAID’s departure, elections in Russia, and whether or not there is room for optimism in the future.

“We are not going to cease operations, but we will have to change the way we operate our projects,” Melkonyants told me, pointing out that funding from USAID was mostly used towards organizational purposes, such as helping election monitors with carpools, renting offices for training seminars, and so on. Golos is active in more than half of Russia’s regions — and Russia is an enormous country, where logistical challenges are plentiful and finding solutions to them can be expensive.

Like most non-governmental projects that are not aligned with the Kremlin, Golos has been dependent on funding from abroad — particularly because Russian businesspeople are loath to cross the authorities and very rarely donate to organizations that displease the ruling officials. “The culture of giving to non-governmental organizations is just now starting to develop,” he said. “Only starting in 2012 can people get a tax exemption on their donations – and while we’ve always had a support system for state care facilities for minors, for sick children, people give political organizations a wide berth.”

Melkonyants was dismissive of the Russian government’s criticism of USAID’s perceived meddling in Russia’s internal affairs. “This kind of international support is done all over the world — Russia does it too,” he said. “When a society is well-developed, it doesn’t only think about itself, it is concerned with spreading the values it deems important … According to the Russian constitution, human rights are our country’s greatest value — therefore, I believe this kind of aid is consistent with our national idea.”

Much as I do, Melkonyants believes that Russia will continue to develop in a positive direction. “Of course, we don’t want any sudden changes,” he said. “We want gradual change — as opposed to sudden, revolution-like changes — because that would not benefit anyone.”

Natalia Antonova is the acting editor in chief of the Moscow News.

Personal Democracy Media is grateful to the Omidyar Network for its generous support of techPresident's WeGov section.

News Briefs

RSS Feed today >

Crowdsourcing Waste Management Solutions in Montenegro

For once we aren't talking about the worldwide scarcity of toilets, just good old-fashioned household waste. Montenegro has a garbage problem so bad even the tourists are complaining about it. A new mobile app sponsored by the Agency for Environmental Protection, NGO Ozon and United Nations Development Programme in Montenegro will hopefully get citizens involved in reporting illegal garbage dumps. GO

monday >

Her Majesty's Government Wants to Monetize Open Data

A new paper from the chair of the U.K. government's Open Strategy Board outlines the best practices for the government's open data policies. The government-commissioned Shakespeare Review – after author Stephan Shakespeare – looks into ways to monetize open data, and recommends an all-encompassing National Data Strategy.

GO

Will Silicon Valley "Disrupt" Politics With a Candidate for Congress?

Sean Parker, of Napster fame and now executive general partner at venture capital firm Founders Fund, has invested in political startups before. But last week, he went a step further — co-hosting a fundraising event for a candidate for Congress. Parker and SV Angel co-founder Ron Conway organized a crowd of Internet industry luminaries to support Ro Khanna, a former assistant deputy secretary in Barack Obama's Commerce Department. Khanna is preparing a challenge to Rep. Mike Honda (D-Calif.), whose newly redrawn congressional district encompasses Silicon Valley. GO

Burma's Upcoming Telecom Revolution Will Probably Not Bring Internet Freedom

Burma (Myanmar) is on the threshold of an Internet revolution, but Human Rights Watch has warned companies to proceed with caution or risk trampling Burmese citizens' rights. GO

friday >

Chilean Anti-Corruption Resource: A Crowdsourced Database of Social and Political Connections

In countries where a small minority of social circles have a majority of the political and economic power, personal relationships can affect major decision-making, a serious concern of anti-corruption activists. A new web platform stores personal profiles of key players in Chilean business and politics, complete with biographies and personal and professional connections through family, education, social circles, employers and coworkers, to make tracking social relationships and conflict-of-interest easier. Called Poderopedia (from the Spanish word for power), the project sounds kind of like LinkedIn, but the creation and management of profiles is being crowdsourced out to journalists, activists and concerned citizens.

GO

Middle Eastern Telecom Accused of Working With Saudi Arabia to Spy on Citizens

Mobily, an arm of the state-owned Middle Eastern telecom giant Etihad Etisalat, has been accused of working with Saudi Arabia to develop software that would allow the government to bypass protections for social media users. The exposé comes from Moxie Marlinspike (neé Matthew Rosenfield), an expert in a certain type of malicious Internet attack called MITM (man-in-the-middle), whereby attackers intercept and secretly alter private messages exchanged via email and other social media platforms. GO

Saudi Religious Leader Warns Twitter Users of Consequences in the Afterlife

In late March, Saudi Arabia's top religious cleric said Twitter was for clowns and corrupters. Earlier this week, he said anyone using social media, in particular Twitter, “has lost this world and the afterlife.” His comments might be laughable, if they did not come at a time when the Saudi government is looking into monitoring or blocking social media sites and eliminating user anonymity.

GO

thursday >

What The Other Silicon Valley Immigration Group Is Doing This Month

A bipartisan coalition of political advocacy, business and tech groups are moving ahead to launch a social media blitz next week designed to persuade members of the Senate to vote in favor of immigration reform legislation supported in Silicon Valley. "We're going to create a virtual digital storm," said Jeremy Robbins in a Wednesday ... GO

The New Yorker Hopes "Strongbox" Is a Wiretap-Proof Sieve for Leaks

The New Yorker yesterday became the first outlet to implement DeadDrop, a new system for sources to submit information to journalists online in a more secure and anonymous way than, for example, email. GO

Female Organizer of Pakistan's First Hackathon Stresses Collaboration Over Competition

After Pakistan banned Valentine's Day this year, Sabeen Mahmud started an online protest in which people uploaded photos to mock the government ban. In the weeks following she received death threats and menacing phone calls, and early on she had to stay home from work. That did nothing, however, to keep her from further organizing. Last month, the café she started in Karachi hosted Pakistan's first ever hackathon, which tackled problems including sanitation, crime, disaster management, and education. She even invited a government representative to observe the initial conversations, tackling sensitive areas like government inefficiency and elections.

GO

wednesday >

White House Innovation Fellows Project Spins Off Into A Business

Clay Johnson and Adam Becker joined the Presidential Innovation Fellows program to help the White House fix the way government does business. Now they're turning that mission into a business themselves. GO

Fighting Fires With Data, New York City Launches New Safety Inspection System

Mayor Michael Bloomberg announced today that New York City has implemented city-wide a new risk based inspection system focused on fire safety that is driven by analytics from multiple city agencies. GO

Chinese Netizens Use Digital Initiative to Gain Media Attention for Unsolved Poisoning Case

Last month a medical science student at a Shanghai university died from poisoning, allegedly murdered by his roommate. The specifics of the crime echoed a case from the mid-1990s, in which a 19-year-old student was poisoned with thallium. That case has once again been thrown into the media spotlight, but after 18 years the media has changed and the spotlight means a trending hashtag on Sina Weibo or an online petition to the U.S. President.

GO

PDF France 2013: “Au Code, Citoyens!”

This year PDF France will take place in Paris on June 13, with the theme "Au Code, Citoyens!" ("To Code, Citizens!") The speakers' lineup includes some of the continent's leaders in the digital revolution. GO

tuesday >

Website Imitation is Flattery in New York City Council Race

A New York City Council candidate who had made his name as a technology consultant and spearheaded an open government initiative several years ago found parts of his website copied by another City Council candidate in a different borough, as Politicker first reported. GO

Mike Honda Locks Up Establishment Support, But Challenger Has Ear of the Silicon Valley Elite

Some of Silicon Valley's most influential business people will hold a fundraiser in San Francisco this Thursday for Ro Khanna, the 36-year-old lawyer who's challenging 71-year-old California Democrat Mike Honda for his 17th Congressional District seat. The names at the top of the invite: Ron Conway and Sean Parker. They're apparently forming a committee to help Khanna build his campaign. The other bold-face names who are listed as part of the 'committee in formation' include Salesforce.com's Founder and CEO Marc Benioff, Benchmark Capital General Partners' Matt Cohler and Peter Fenton, tech entrepreneur Shawn Fanning, Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer, her big data venture investor husband Zach Bogue, and Conway's SV Angel colleague, Founder and Managing Partner David Lee. GO

More