Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

Is Sina Weibo a Means of Free Speech or a Means of Social Control?

BY David Eaves | Friday, August 17 2012

Photo: Francisco Diaz / Flickr

During a trip to Beijing last week, I had an opportunity to sit down for dinner with Chinese journalist, blogger and media expert Michael Anti.

For those who have not had an opportunity to see it I suggest taking a look at his 2012 Personal Democracy Forum presentation, Walking Along the Great Firewall.

Over noodles Anti spoke about Chinese social media, and in particular how services like Sina Weibo — a Chinese version of Twitter — is not a decentralizing force in Chinese politics. The political impact of certain Weibo services are significant. According to Bloomberg, Weibo has over 300 million registered users, with top celebrity users attracting over 20 million followers. Since Weibo allows individuals to criticize government officials, it has widely been seen as a “freer” form of media, one that could empower citizens to hold the government to account (and thus decentralize power). Western media has been keen to note instances where Weibo services subverted government officials, be it on a large scale, such as in the aftermath of the high speed rail crash in July of 2011, or small events, such as students organizing an alternative venue for a lecture after a university cancelled it.

However, Anti’s argument is that Weibo tweets can be harnessed and shaped by a central authority — the managers of Sina Weibo, acting on behalf of the Chinese central government.

Think of it this way. Imagine Sina Weibo is a pipe carrying a torrent of water (tweets) that can be managed with various valves. While it may be possible to occasionally to tighten all the valves and turn the service off altogether it is better to allow many tweets to flow so as to not let pressure to build up. It is better to give people the sense that they can complain about issues, people and politics — it is a powerful outlet. What is critical is to ensure any torrent of complaints is never directed at the ultimate authority, the central government. The trick to achieving this is to shape the flow of tweets. In the case of Sina Weibo, Anti believes that tweets that are critical of the central government are essentially always censored. In other words that valve always stays off. However, while tweets complaining about local and regional governments corruption or ineptness are often permitted, they can, of course, be turned off by banning certain key words, or selectively deleting certain tweets or accounts. But, this is a discretionary choice.

Further reading

For non-Chinese speakers interested in learning more about the types of conversations taking place over Sina Weibo and other social media platforms in China, Personal Democracy Forum 2012 speaker David Wertime co-founded a site called Tea Leaf Nation that monitors and translates these online conversations. It is a fascinating resource for those interested in learning more about how Chinese netizens are reacting to, and creating, news in one of the most important countries in the world.

Thus those who control Sina Weibo basically have their fingers on some important valves — they can control what complaints get through, how much these critical tweets gain traction, and how big an online “protest” can become.

This has several interesting implications. The most important is that contrary to what many might expect, Weibo actually centralizes control. This is because it is now in the power of Sina Weibo (or the central party) to control how much public pressure is brought on a government. Thus if a government wants to squelch an online campaign against it, it needs the help of the central government — something that may come free, or at a price. It gives the central government still more leverage.

In addition, it would seem to suggest that the Communist Party has also outsourced censorship to a private company. It is unlikely that party officials can monitor all the tweets going through Weibo, as a result, they likely rely a fair bit on Weibo staff to monitor and manage traffic. Indeed, this Time magazine article suggests that Weibo has 1,000 employees whose job is focused on sifting through and censoring its users.

It also reveals what both Anti and I agree will be a signature issue for the 21st century. The person who controls the servers can have enormous influence over the discourse. This is thus also a dark warning about the way services like Facebook or Twitter could be abused should some unsavory characters take control of the algorithms that drive it or, of course, their their commercial interests make it compelling. While I would have thought it implausible three weeks ago, a future in which Twitter throttles tweets complaining about certain partners or advertisers still feels unlikely, but no longer impossible.

That said, enormous influence does not always equate complete control. Even Anti felt that manipulating the valves of Weibo will not permanently protect the central government. If more and more pressure is brought on local and regional governments, and they are ultimately forced to reform, people's attention will eventually be harder and harder to turn away from the central government — especially if there are models for reform at the regional level. In the end, over tea, Anti suggested that the valves can’t stop the flow, but by directing it, it can buy you time, and potentially lots of it. That appears to be what the Communist Party is hoping.

Personal Democracy Media is grateful to the Omidyar Network for its generous support of techPresident's WeGov section.

News Briefs

RSS Feed today >

The Rise and Fall of Iran's “Blogestan”

The robust community of Iranian bloggers—sometimes nicknamed “Blogestan”—has shrunk since its heyday between 2002 – 2010. “Whither Blogestan,” a recent report from the University of Pennsylvania's Iran Media Program sought to find out how and why. The researchers performed a web crawling analysis of Blogestan, survey 165 Persian blog users, and conducted 20 interviews with influential bloggers in the Persian community. They found multiple causes of the decline in blogging, including increased social media use and interference from authorities.


tuesday >

Weekly Readings: What the Govt Wants to Know

A roundup of interesting reads and stories from around the web. GO

Russia to Treat Bloggers Like Mass Media Because "the F*cking Journalists Won't Stop Writing"

The worldwide debate over who is and who isn't a journalist has raged since digital media made it much easier for citizen journalists and other “amateurs” to compete with the big guys. In the United States, journalists are entitled to certain protections under the law, such as the right to confidential sources. As such, many argue that blogging should qualify as journalism because independent writers deserve the same legal protections as corporate employees. In Russia, however, earning a place equal to mass media means additional regulations and obligations, which some say will lead to the repression of free speech.


Politics for People: Demanding Transparent and Ethical Lobbying in the EU

Today the Alliance for Lobbying Transparency and Ethics Regulation (ALTER-EU) launched a campaign called Politics for People that asks candidates for the European Parliament to pledge to stand up to secretive industry lobbyists and to advocate for transparency. The Politics for People website connects voters with information about their MEP candidates and encourages them to reach out on Facebook, Twitter or by email to ask them to sign the pledge.


monday >

Security Agencies Given Full Access to Telecom Data Even Though "All Lebanese Can Not Be Suspects"

In late March, Lebanese government ministers granted security agencies unrestricted access to telecommunications data in spite of some ministers objections that it violates privacy rights. Global Voices reports that the policy violates Lebanon's existing surveillance and privacy law, Law 140, but has gotten little coverage from the country's mainstream media.


friday >

In Google Hangout, NYC Mayor de Blasio Talks Tech and Outer Borough Potential

New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio followed the lead of President Obama and New York City Council member Ben Kallos Friday by participating in a Google Hangout to help mark his first 100 days in office, in which the conversation focused on expanding access to technology opportunities through education and ensuring that the needs of the so-called "outer boroughs" aren't overlooked. GO

thursday >

In Pakistan, A Hypocritical Gov't Ignores Calls To End YouTube Ban

YouTube has been blocked in Pakistan by executive order since September 2012, after the “blasphemous” video Innocence of Muslims started riots in the Middle East. Since then, civil society organizations and Internet rights advocacy groups like Bolo Bhi and Bytes for All have been working to lift the ban. Last August the return of YouTube seemed imminent—the then-new IT Minister Anusha Rehman spoke optimistically and her party, which had won the majority a few months before, was said to be “seriously contemplating” ending the ban. And yet since then, Rehman and her party, the conservative Pakistan Muslim League (PML-N), have done everything in their power to maintain the status quo.


The #NotABugSplat Campaign Aims to Give Drone Operators Pause Before They Strike

In the #NotABugSplat campaign that launched this week, a group of American, French and Pakistani artists sought to raise awareness of the effects of drone strikes by placing a field-sized image of a young girl, orphaned when a drone strike killed her family, in a heavily targeted region of Pakistan’s Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Province. Its giant size is visible to those who operate drone strikes as well as in satellite imagery. GO

Boston and Cambridge Move Towards More Open Data

The Boston City Council is now considering an ordinance which would require Boston city agencies and departments to make government data available online using open standards. Boston City Councilor At Large Michelle Wu, who introduced the legislation Wednesday, officially announced her proposal Monday, the same day Boston Mayor Martin Walsh issued an executive order establishing an open data policy under which all city departments are directed to publish appropriate data sets under established accessibility, API and format standards. GO

YouTube Still Blocked In Turkey, Even After Courts Rule It Violates Human Rights, Infringes on Free Speech

Reuters reports that even after a Turkish court ruled to lift the ban on YouTube, Turkey's telecommunications companies continue to block the video sharing site.


wednesday >

Everything You Need to Know About Social Media and India's General Election

The biggest democratic election in the world to date is taking place in India from April 7 to May 14, and, for the first time in India, the results might hinge on who runs a better social media campaign. The Mumbai research firm Iris Knowledge Foundation has said that Facebook will “wield a tremendous influence” but Indian politicians are not limiting their attentions to India's most popular social media platform. In addition to virtual campaigning are initiatives to inform, educate and encourage Indians to participate in their democracy.