Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

Further Down the Ballot, Little Love for a "Social Voting" Tool

BY Sarah Lai Stirland | Monday, November 5 2012

Rachel Norton, a vice president of the San Francisco Board of Education, says Votizen's interface "leaves a lot to desired."

It’s almost Election Day. If you’re in the United States, it’s highly unlikely that you have escaped contact from a political campaign, be it through the mail, phone, in-person visit from a campaign volunteer, text message or television ad.

You might also have been contacted through a friend on Facebook — and if that's the case, it may have been by an organization using technology from the San Francisco startup Votizen. Votizen is hoping to build a Yelp-like service for political candidates. The idea is that candidates can ask supporters to endorse them on social media — then to go a step further, and ask those supporters to convince their friends who are eligible to vote for the candidate to get out and do so.

Votizen was one of the first movers in a growing political field that looks to harness social media data about real voters in ways that campaigns can use to get out the vote. Its platform, which offers campaign supporters the ability to declare their endorsement of a candidate and then look through their social networks for friends who are also voters, made an early splash last year by debuting as part of San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee's election campaign. But there are other platforms that do similar work, and Votizen's use cases pale in comparison to deployments of competing services on behalf of Obama for America, labor groups working on the Wisconsin recall effort, and even Mitt Romney's presidential campaign.

The idea that new tools could make voting social has taken off among high-level campaigns that understand the power of one-to-one connections online. But at the grassroots, where Votizen's co-founders hope to grow most of their clients, this seed of an idea has yet to sprout.

Local candidates and their representatives said that they simply didn’t have the bandwidth to learn how to use a new online tool, or that it didn’t fit with their targeted audience. Interviews with one of the company's co-founders and some of the campaigns putting the system to the test suggest Votizen is being put to use by large institutions that want to quickly deploy "social voting" technology, but the company has a long way to go before it can serve as an effective platform for widespread civic engagement around the most local campaigns.

“The thing about these down-ticket races is that people do not even know [the names of the candidates],” Putorti said. “That’s where friends play a big role. Getting down to the local stuff, that’s where the technology shines big time. There’s a big opportunity there, by just trying to get the recommendation, and the name recognition.”

Votizen has 5,500 campaigns in its system, 200 of which are paying customers. Just under 100,000 people are using Votizen to campaign on behalf of candidates, according to Putorti. But the results there are not exactly eye-catching.

Asked to highlight examples of deployments where Votizen had a significant impact, he offered a Tea Party candidate, Byron Donalds, who lost a five-way House primary in Florida in August. There, a single volunteer drove 1,391 messages from 103 supporters.

"Given this race was decided by a few thousand votes, and this candidate didn't even rate in the Cook Report, I'd say we had a material impact in this primary," Putorti said.

In contrast, Votizen seems to be doing steady business with larger organizations hoping to leverage social connections between their supporters and people in Votizen's database of 200 million registered voters.

On Friday for example, MoveOn.org Political Action sent an e-mail out to its seven million members asking them to participate in an online voter-turnout program called “Vote Buddy.” MoveOn is using a Facebook app developed by the nonprofit Fight for the Future that enables people to prominently pledge to vote on Facebook, and to invite their network of Facebook friends to do exactly the same thing via Facebook messages. Users of the app can see which of their invited Facebook friends have pledged to vote, and which of them have voted in the past. Then, they can follow up on Election Day to send their pledges reminders and e-mail queries. The data on friends’ voting histories comes from Votizen’s database.

Fight for the Future’s mastermind, Tiffiniy Cheng, says that several organizations — including Planned Parenthood — also plan to send out invitations to people on their email lists inviting them to pledge to vote. (Full disclosure: Personal Democracy Media is working with Fight for the Future on "The Internet Votes" projects, with funding from the Ford Foundation, to promote the use of Vote With Friends.)

These organizations seem better equipped to take advantage of Votizen's features, but they're not the groups Votizen's co-founders say they saw themselves courting as clients — at least not in this way.

In November 2011, not long after rolling out the platform for the first time, Votizen co-founder David Binetti told techPresident that the platform's goal was "to connect voters to the issues they care about, officials, candidates and ultimately each other." It would be paid for, they said at the time, by providing two services: One to charge issue organizations to print and mail issue letters from citizens who speak out on the Votizen platform, and another to charge campaigns for the opportunity to reach out to people who indicate through Votizen that they're willing to vote for one candidate or the other.

Instead, issue organizations are in essence leasing access to Votizen's database, while the down-ballot candidates Putorti was hoping to reach out to say they don't have the time to put Votizen to use or have tried and did not see it succeed.

"I think people are a little inundated by their FB pages these days with people inviting them to events etc," Rachel Norton, an incumbent member of the San Francisco Board of Education using Votizen in her re-election campaign, wrote to me in an email. "I know I am -- so it doesn't feel as easy and effortless as clicking "Like". It seems like the tool will need a lot more ways to engage my friends so that they want to engage their own friends."

She continued:

I think if I were running a bigger campaign or assigned this task to a volunteer, I might have had more results.

I continue to think the tool has huge potential - they just have to work on the interface a bit and maybe tighten the way it interfaces with other social tools.

Norton said she was trying to write a pitch and send it out to all of her Facebook friends in San Francisco to ask for her vote, which Putorti responds is not the way the tool is supposed to work. The tool is supposed to allow Norton's supporters to log on and ask their friends to support her.

"To get the most out of the product, you need to actually put a lot of supporters on it, and have them send messages out," Putorti wrote in an email. "You get out of this system what you put in, just like a field/grassroots campaign."

Norton is one of about half a dozen local candidates interviewed for this article, most of whom said they saw the potential in Votizen but not the reward.

Anand Singh, field director for San Francisco Board of Supervisors candidate F.X. Crowley, said that District 7 — the district in which I live — has a lot of older voters, which is what inspired the 53-year-old native San Franciscan to keep his campaign “traditional.”

His competitor Joel Engardio, one of seven others, told me that he didn’t have time.

“I have not been using the Votizen site,” Engardio said. “Somebody signed me up for it, but I just haven’t had the opportunity to use it, but I have been using Facebook and YouTube, and a website.”

Votizen, founded three years ago, was established on the premise that voters' peer-to-peer influence through online social networks could fundamentally change the way elections operate in the same way that Napster disrupted established business relationships in the music industry. Its big-name backers include SV Angel, Ashton Kutcher, Sean Parker, and a range of other celebrities.

They're experimenting with new products in the hopes of reaching that goal, like a recently-launched project called Votizen Live, which maps tweets to real voters in their geographic locations. Votizen's tool to let supporters spot voters from among their social networks comes with a flat fee for each campaign, rather than the model Putorti originally planned. Instead of charging per voter, a flat rate lets campaigns enable supporters to find voters among their Facebook friends or Twitter followers, reach out in an effort to solicit their pledge to vote, and then give them tools to follow up on Election Day so that voter might stand a better chance of making it to the polls.

But the company still hasn't overcome hesitance from small campaigns, or perhaps from voters, to try new things.

"People are usually pretty hesitant — even myself — even if I do decide to vote for someone, I usually won't commit by clicking on this link, or telling you right now. I want to take some time to think about this a little more," said Kalen Gallagher, a 29-year-old education entrepreneur and lawyer who has used Votizen to activate his network of friends to vote for him to be a member of the Campbell Union High School Board in San Jose.

That doesn't mean the platform isn't working. Gallagher has dozens and dozens of friends sending out messages to their networks of friends who are voters in his district. He's using Votizen as part of a more conventional strategy that includes phone banks, door-to-door canvassing, mailers, Facebook ads and lawn signs. Votizen cost him a $100 fee for the duration of his campaign. It just isn't delivering the social-media response Gallagher was hoping for.

Putorti expects it will take a few more years before a market for social voting really starts to grow. The real test for Votizen will be in 2014, when Los Angeles votes for for a new mayor, and in 2013 when New York elects a mayor and Virginia votes for a new governor.

"Until they see proof that this is the future, campaigns will continue to be risk averse," he wrote in an e-mail. "In 2008, only a handful of campaigns did online fundraising; now everyone is. Disruptive technologies are ignored, then laughed at, then accepted."

"Startups are by their very nature experiments, until they're hugely successful," he said when asked how he thinks Votizen is doing. "My vision for the future is not about giving campaigns better tools, it's about allowing people to self-organize online and force candidates to pitch them and compete for their votes. When I get a new candidate to run in a district, and win, because they pitched a group of voters on Votizen, I'll consider that a win. When I remake politics so that the primary way votes are won is no longer (attack) television ads, but voters are back at the center, then I'll be where I want to be."

This post has been updated to include a disclosure of Personal Democracy Media's relationship with Fight for the Future in support of its work on "The Internet Votes" project and the Vote With Friends app.

News Briefs

RSS Feed today >

Please Stop Selling MOOCs As a Cure-All for Higher Education

Massive open online courses, or MOOCs, promise to provide cheap or free college courses to any student with a Wi-Fi connection, but that's about it. Funny, then, that someone would suggest otherwise. Funnier still, because that someone is Anant Agarwal, the president of edX, in a recent piece that appeared on the Guardian's website. GO

Brazil's Middle Class Protestors Take the Struggle Online, With Mixed Results

Protestors in Brazil have made their war cry heard all over social media and as a result, have received quite a bit of attention from the international community with popular hashtags such as #itsnotabout20cents and #ChangeBrazil. But while they have used tools like Facebook to organize and rally, the effectiveness of their Twitter use is harder to gauge. GO

The Thicker China's "Great Firewall" Becomes, the Subtler the Doors to Sneak Through

As China announces it will tighten restrictions on access to the Internet, Chinese citizens show that they've developed new ways around them. GO

tuesday >

Cory Booker Hires Democratic Organizing Veteran Addisu Demissie To Manage Senate Run

Newark Mayor Cory Booker has hired a veteran of the Democratic organizing world Addisu Demissie to manage his run to succeed the late New Jersey Democratic Senator Frank Lautenberg of New Jersey. GO

ShareProgress Debuts Social Sharing Optimization Tools

ShareProgress, a left-leaning tech startup in downtown San Francisco, launched its social sharing optimization platform Tuesday after several months of testing with the progressive advocacy group CREDO Action. GO

New Organizing Institute to Move from Collecting Election Data to Organizing Election Officials

The New Organizing Institute, a progressive nonprofit that trains campaigners and is no led by former Obama for America data director Ethan Roeder, is launching a new initiative next week aiming to "fix that" for local elections. NOI will announce a national network where local election administration officials can congregate to share solutions to common issues. It's a transition for a team at NOI that had previously been managing the Voting Information Project, which collects data on polling places, election districts and voter registration deadlines and prepares it for third parties in machine-readable format. In the 2012 election cycle, backed by the Pew Charitable Trusts and partnered with Google, VIP made information available in all 50 states. GO

Russian SOPA Passed First Reading

A first draft of a law nicknamed “Russian SOPA” was approved by the Russian parliament last Friday, June 14. Like the original Stop Online Piracy Act, the bill will establish penalties and procedures for online copyright violations.

GO

monday >

Czech Prime Minister Resigns Following Corruption and Surveillance Scandal

The prime minister of the Czech Republic resigned yesterday, irreparably damaged by a corruption scandal and the possibility of impropriety in his personal life. According to the Czech constitution, his entire government will also have to relinquish office.

GO

friday >

Mayors of New York City and San Francisco Announce "Digital Cities" Summit

The Mayors of New York City and San Francisco announced Friday that they're co-hosting meetings in the Fall and early next year to examine the "best practices" that lead to tech-enabled economic growth. The meetings are follow-ups to the initial Bloomberg Technology Summit held last year in New York City. This year's summit in New York ... GO

New York State Joins GitHub to Get Feedback on Open Data Policy

New York is the first state to publish an initial draft of its open data guidelines on GitHub to seek feedback from the public, Governor Andrew Cuomo announced in a press release Thursday. GO

Brazilians Protest Forced Evictions on YouTube and in Mock World Cup

Tomorrow Brazilians who have been forced out of their housing in advance of the 2014 World Cup will stage their own “People's Cup” in Rio de Janeiro to draw awareness to forced evictions.

GO

A “Fix-Rate” for Corruption: Integrity Action Wins the Google Global Impact Award

“From wanachi (“citizen”) to up there,” Emmanuel Dzombo explains with an upward sweep of his hand, is how Integrity Action has begun to reverse the bureaucratic top-down approach that has often blocked development work in Kenya. Dzombo is a local leader in Chengoni, Kenya, a country that ranks towards the very bottom of Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index – at 139. The organization believes it could do more, and Google.org seems to agree. The Google Impact Challenge will provide the charity with £500,000 that will allow it to develop a mobile application for tracking and collecting data from citizens. GO

Crowdsourced "Danger Maps" Track Air, Soil and Water Pollution in China

Chinese citizens are exposing sources of pollution and other environmental problems by contributing to the partially crowdsourced website 'Danger Maps'. So far, the Chinese government is letting them get away with it.

GO

thursday >

U.S. Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board To Meet Next Wednesday

A long dormant independent agency that was at least nominally supposed to exercise a modicum of oversight over the booming intelligence-industrial complex is scrambling to meet up next Wednesday, but the public will still be none the wiser about what it plans to do, since it is a closed door meeting. The only indication that the toothless ... GO

Despite Software Problems, Civic Hackers are Pedaling Bike Share Data

Reporters are shoaling around the news that New York City's new bike sharing system, Citi Bike, is benighted with problems stemming from its high-tech software. But that's not putting the brakes on plans to explore what programmers might do with data generated by the system by hosting a Citi Bike Civic Hack Night later this month. GO

Grassroots Republicans Are Not Waiting for the RNC To Revamp Their Digital Strategy

Several members of the Republican Party rank and file aren't waiting around for the GOP to reinvent itself on the technological front. They're organizing events themselves to explore what a tech-enabled GOP might look like for the 2014 cycle. GO

More