Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

#PDF12: The Radical Power of the Internet Public

BY Micah L. Sifry | Wednesday, June 13 2012

Chris Soghoian at Personal Democracy Forum 2012. Photo: Esty Stein / PDM

Tuesday morning at PDF12, there were five quick keynote talks in a row that could serve as a 50-minute primer on the radical power of the Internet public to change the world, why it's so important to nurture that public, where some of the threats to the Internet are coming from, and how people are routing around them to build a future "intranet" that might well stand free from governmental and corporate control.

They were, in order, from Chris Soghoian, Dave Parry, Peter Fein, Sascha Meinrath and Deanna Zandt. You can watch them in order below.

Soghoian kicked things off by explaining why the apparent use of powerful malware by the United States government was as troubling as the CIA's use of a vaccination program in Pakistan to attempt to get information on the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden. "Immunization saves lives," he argued, and doctors groups have complained to the CIA that using doctors as spooks will cause people to distrust medical workers and thus reduce the effectiveness of vaccination programs. And that can not only harm people we say we're trying to help, the effects can blow back on all of us, as the world's population grows more interconnected. In the same way, he argued that the new FLAME supervirus, which appears to be targeting computers in the Arab world and which takes advantage of security flaws in web browser update tools, could have the effect of causing fewer people to trust the auto-updates that they receive from companies like Microsoft and Google. Which would make it easier for their computers to be turned into zombies used by bot-nets for all kinds of malicious activity.

Then Dave Parry offered a rousing defense of the "internet public," a term that he coined during the Arab Spring. "It's not about the internet," he said, "it's about the social effects of the internet" and the effects it has on people and what it means to be a "public." Channeling Marshall McLuhan, he explained how the medium through which we communicate changes social relations between people and thus changes the society we live in. Ten years ago, he noted, If the Komen Foundation had changed its policy on funding Planned Parenthood breast-cancer screening, little would have happened. Now, anger gets expressed visibly, socially, and publicly, in ways that can have political impact. "The internet public is the best form of media public we have ever had, but increasingly corporations and governments are trying to return us to a broadcast public." He called for fighting back aggressively to defend the internet public, and pointed to two examples: raising money to punish bad politicians or elect better ones, and EnemyGraph, a Facebook app that undermines Facebook's social graph--meant to give you positive relationships with products and companies--and enables people to show what they "dislike" on that site.

Parry was followed by Peter Fein, an agent with Telecomix, a hacker collective that among other things, helped do tech support for the Arab Spring. His provocative talk argued that representative democracy was out of date because "we've found better ways of doing something that are cheaper, faster and scale to larger numbers of people." Adhocracy empowered by networked, he said, is that better way, and he used his own experiences with Telecomix to illustrate that point.

"Telecomix is an adhoc activist cluster of a few hundred humans and machines- programmers, network admins, students, punks, politicians, pirates, parents and others….We have no formal members, we have no leaders, we have no permanent subgroups. We're all volunteers - we take no money at all, we have no mailing address, there's nowhere you can send a package. We certainly have no official spokespeople. If Telecomix exists anywhere, it's in our chat networks and the relationships of the people who participate. We operate on a simple principle: you show up, find collaborators, and just go do.

After that, Sascha Meinrath of the Open Technology Institute took the stage to talk about the "rise of the Intranet era." He gave a capsule history of the rise of mesh networking, from something the FCC didn't even believe existed, to something that is now spreading in metro areas all over the world. It was a mind-blowing illustration of a future that already exists--an internet that will exist beyond the control of governments and corporations. From the Detroit Digital Justice Coalition, which is supplying free connectivity to people in one neighborhood there, to Guifi Net in Catalonia and FreiFunk in Austria, which are covering huge areas and thousands of users, Meinrath showed the "Borg-like" expansion of local mesh networking, most of which is completely free. "This is a global movement transforming how people are thinking about communications, and it's happening today," he declared.

Batting clean-up was Deanna Zandt, media technologist and author of the book Share This!, who used her recent experience setting up the Tumblr blog "Planned Parenthood Saved Me" to illustrate the differences between ad-hoc power, networked power and hierarchical power. In the first case, people rapidly come together around a common concern, express themselves, and disperse. In the second case, people have prior shared connections and beliefs and use the trust they have built together to self-consciously move with some coordination. And in the third, resources like money and command-and-control systems allow people at the top to get others to do their bidding. Her talk offers a subtle analysis of how all three of these kinds of power matter, and expanded our understanding of how ad-hoc networks can be highly useful in reaching people who aren't already linked in. Planned Parenthood, in this case, used its top-down power to get the alarm out about the Komen Foundation change in policy regarding funding breast cancer screenings, but then it got out of the way, allowing networks like Deanna's and the larger informal reaction of thousands of outraged women sharing their stories to challenge Komen's decision. For Deanna, the episode illustrated how, thanks to the Internet, ad-hoc and bottom-up networks are starting to take on and defeat hierarchies, a vision of the future many in the audience found compelling.

News Briefs

RSS Feed monday >

Czech Prime Minister Resigns Following Corruption and Surveillance Scandal

The prime minister of the Czech Republic resigned yesterday, irreparably damaged by a corruption scandal and the possibility of impropriety in his personal life. According to the Czech constitution, his entire government will also have to relinquish office.

GO

The Disappearance of Greece's Fourth Estate

On June 11 the Greek government abruptly announced the immediate closure of the country's state-owned public broadcasting company, ERT (Hellenic Radio and Television), in what they said was a cost-cutting measure. The move, which came with no prior discussion, puts 2,750 people out of work, in a country with an official unemployment rate that is nearly 27 percent. It also makes Greece the only European Union member state without a public broadcasting service. GO

friday >

Mayors of New York City and San Francisco Announce "Digital Cities" Summit

The Mayors of New York City and San Francisco announced Friday that they're co-hosting meetings in the Fall and early next year to examine the "best practices" that lead to tech-enabled economic growth. The meetings are follow-ups to the initial Bloomberg Technology Summit held last year in New York City. This year's summit in New York ... GO

New York State Joins GitHub to Get Feedback on Open Data Policy

New York is the first state to publish an initial draft of its open data guidelines on GitHub to seek feedback from the public, Governor Andrew Cuomo announced in a press release Thursday. GO

Brazilians Protest Forced Evictions on YouTube and in Mock World Cup

Tomorrow Brazilians who have been forced out of their housing in advance of the 2014 World Cup will stage their own “People's Cup” in Rio de Janeiro to draw awareness to forced evictions.

GO

A “Fix-Rate” for Corruption: Integrity Action Wins the Google Global Impact Award

“From wanachi (“citizen”) to up there,” Emmanuel Dzombo explains with an upward sweep of his hand, is how Integrity Action has begun to reverse the bureaucratic top-down approach that has often blocked development work in Kenya. Dzombo is a local leader in Chengoni, Kenya, a country that ranks towards the very bottom of Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index – at 139. The organization believes it could do more, and Google.org seems to agree. The Google Impact Challenge will provide the charity with £500,000 that will allow it to develop a mobile application for tracking and collecting data from citizens. GO

Crowdsourced "Danger Maps" Track Air, Soil and Water Pollution in China

Chinese citizens are exposing sources of pollution and other environmental problems by contributing to the partially crowdsourced website 'Danger Maps'. So far, the Chinese government is letting them get away with it.

GO

thursday >

U.S. Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board To Meet Next Wednesday

A long dormant independent agency that was at least nominally supposed to exercise a modicum of oversight over the booming intelligence-industrial complex is scrambling to meet up next Wednesday, but the public will still be none the wiser about what it plans to do, since it is a closed door meeting. The only indication that the toothless ... GO

Despite Software Problems, Civic Hackers are Pedaling Bike Share Data

Reporters are shoaling around the news that New York City's new bike sharing system, Citi Bike, is benighted with problems stemming from its high-tech software. But that's not putting the brakes on plans to explore what programmers might do with data generated by the system by hosting a Citi Bike Civic Hack Night later this month. GO

Grassroots Republicans Are Not Waiting for the RNC To Revamp Their Digital Strategy

Several members of the Republican Party rank and file aren't waiting around for the GOP to reinvent itself on the technological front. They're organizing events themselves to explore what a tech-enabled GOP might look like for the 2014 cycle. GO

wednesday >

New Russian Law Makes Publication of Information on Gay Rights Illegal

On June 11 the Russian parliament passed a bill against “homosexual propaganda” that effectively outlaws gay rights rallies and bans informational or pro-gay rights material from publication in the media or on the Internet. Violators of the law will risk heavy fines and censorship and, in the case of a media outlet, risk being shut down. It had near unanimous support, passing in a 436-to-0 vote, with only one abstention.

GO

Macedonia Draft Law to Regulate and Restrict the "Last Arena for Freedom of Speech"

The draft of a media regulation law in Macedonia has journalists and press freedom watchdogs up in arms. The proposed Law on Media and Audiovisual Media Services was written by the government behind closed doors and without input from the media or NGOs. It has been interpreted as a decisive move on the part of the government to limit speech online in a country where press freedoms are already limited. Until now, Internet-based news sites were not regulated like print media.

GO

Trying to Prosecute Online Piracy in Canada? Good Luck!

A private firm that is monitoring Canadians who download pirated content online has found itself at the center of a legal battle. GO

tuesday >

In Kenya, Apps Fizzle Out After Winning Competitions

This spring, Kenyan tech blogger Kennedy Kachwanya left the regional Microsoft Imagine Cup competition thoroughly underwhelmed by the quality of the apps presented. He then wrote an impassioned post (in his words, a rant) on his website Kachwanya.com about the decline of the Kenyan mobile app. He is also outraged because even winning apps seem to fall off the map – basically fail – after the competition is over and media coverage dies down.

GO

Companies and Internet Activists to Congress: Investigate Potential NSA Surveillance Overreach

Over 80 advocacy organizations and Internet companies including Free Press and Mozilla have launched what they are calling a global petition to Congress calling for an inquiry into the scope and scale of reported government surveillance and reforms to the Patriot Act, the FISA Amendment Act and the state secrets privilege. GO

Canada Has its Own Version of PRISM, Reveals Toronto Newspaper

While it may not have a Bond film-worthy name like PRISM, it turns out Canada has a surveillance program of its own. Canadian news outlet The Globe and Mail learned about the program through Access to Information requests filed with the government. They sifted through hundred of records, although extensive passages were redacted for reasons of national security so there are still lingering questions and concerns.

GO

More