Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

[OP-ED] Americans Elect: They Built It, And Nobody Came

BY David Karpf | Friday, May 4 2012

David Karpf: Americans Elect suffers from the "Field of Dreams Fallacy." Photo: Ron Cogswell

David Karpf is an Assistant Professor in the Rutgers University School of Communication and Information, as well as a Faculty Associate in the Eagleton Institute of Politics. His new book, The MoveOn Effect: The Unexpected Transformation of American Political Advocacy, comes out May 30. He will also be speaking at Personal Democracy Forum 2012.

Via DailyKos, Americans Elect has postponed their online "caucuses" for a month. The problem, it seems, is twofold:

1. They don't have a candidate.

2. Lacking a candidate, they don't have much online traffic.

I've written about this before, in relation to my spiffy new hat. But the lesson here deserves further examination. I'm going to go ahead and call this one a failure. If the mainstream media blitz and SXSW awards of the past year haven't generated enthusiasm, it isn't going to appear out of the ether in the 11 days between now and May 15th first "caucus." What's more, Americans Elect is evidence of a common misunderstanding of Internet politics. Elsewhere, I've termed this the "Field of Dreams Fallacy."

The Field of Dreams Fallacy ("if you build it, they will come") plagues all sorts of expensive, half-baked projects in online politics. A few years ago, dozens of interest groups looked at the success of social networking sites like Facebook and became convinced that they should launch their own, branded social networks. Millions of dollars later, it turned out that they were all building virtual ghost towns. Technology alone doesn't create political communities. If your members are already happily on Facebook, they're unlikely to divert that time and spend it on a Sierra Club- or NRA-specific social network instead. The real successes in online politics comes at the intersection of motivated communities-of-interest and supportive technological platforms.

Americans Elect was founded on the gimmicky premise that the power of the Internet would "break the gridlock of Washington" by letting online citizens vote in their own non-party primary. Set aside the obvious flaws in that premise (putting a candidate on the ballot does not elect them to office. Electing a president doesn't remove the gridlock-inducing Senate filibuster.). An awful lot of citizens already vote in primaries -- Mitt Romney has received over 5 million votes in the Republican primaries, and he's constantly criticized for being unpopular. In a country of 311 million mostly-disaffected citizens, one can certainly make that case. The promise of Americans Elect is that the Internet be a bridge to involvement for the rest of us.

From St Paul, MN's Tri-City Herald, we get the following indicator of just how unfulfilled that promise has been:

Ileana Wachtel, a spokeswoman for the group, says no one gathered enough online "clicks" to qualify. Candidates must show they have the backing of at least 1,000 people in at least 10 states. Some candidates must reach a threshold of 5,000 supporters in each of 10 states because they haven't held high enough office before under the Americans Elect bylaws.

"It is their responsibility to get the clicks," Wachtel said. "We are just merely the platform for them to run on."

Ron Paul is currently the most popular "draft candidate" (meaning he hasn't actually agreed to run) with 8,753 supporters on the site. Compared to Ron Paul's online fanbase, that's an abysmally small number. The most popular declared candidate (meaning he's actually agree to run) is Buddy Roemer, with 4,389 supporters. I spoke to Wachtel and asked where the influx of additional activity is expected to come from. She noted that the declared candidates and draft campaigns are "working hard" to drum up support, and said they'd reevaluate on May 15th if the 1,000-people-in-10-states threshold had not been reached.

Pay attention to that last line from Wachtel, though: "It's their responsibility to get the clicks... We are just merely the platform for them to run on." That's ridiculous. AmericansElect has spent the better part of a year shamelessly self-promoting the revolutionary power of this platform. Now it turns out they've thrown a party and no one has shown up, and it seems their response is to blame the guests. 466,000 people have "liked" Americans Elect on Facebook and 10,803 Twitter followers. That's support for the platform. When presented with the top three options of Buddy Roemer, Rocky Anderson, and Michaelene Risly, that support evaporates. (And even if it stayed strong, 466,000 is a lot smaller than Mitt Romney's 5,000,000+ votes.)

Americans Elect is the best example of the Field of Dreams Fallacy I have ever observed. The organization spent a reported $9 million building a cutting edge platform, assuming that high-priced technology and a mainstream media blitz would result in a centrist groundswell that revolutionizes American politics. It built no participatory community, and assumed that the Internet would magically serve one up for them. The result has been an all-too-predictable failure.

Maybe, just maybe, this was prove a high-enough profile blunder that we'll learn something from it about the limits of online politics from it. The lowered transaction costs of the web help to reveal the true demand curve for citizen politics. That can prove transformative -- particularly around issues where there's pent-up demand, but traditionally high barriers to participation. That's not the case with voting, however. The barriers to voting aren't very high. People don't follow politics because they don't like politics. For issues where no one was particularly motivated, and barriers were already pretty low, the new media environment doesn't change outcomes. There is no radical center in American politics. Build the nicest platform money can buy for a disinterested population and you're still going to be left hearing the chirp of online crickets.

Next time, wealthy donors who want to improve the quality of American democracy should keep the Field of Dreams Fallacy in mind. It will lead them to smarter investment decisions.

News Briefs

RSS Feed today >

Another Co-Opted Hashtag: #MustSeeIran

The Twitter hashtag #MustSeeIran was created to showcase Iran's architecture, landscapes, and would-be tourist destinations. It was then co-opted by activists to bring attention to human rights abuses and infringements. Now Twitter is home to two starkly different portraits of a country. GO

At NETmundial Brazil: Is "Multistakeholderism" Good for the Internet?

Today and tomorrow Brazil is hosting NETmundial, a global multi-stakeholder meeting on the future of Internet governance. GO

Brazilian President Signs Internet Bill of Rights Into Law at NetMundial

Earlier today Brazil's President Dilma Rousseff sanctioned Marco Civil, also called the Internet bill of rights, during the global Internet governance event, NetMundial, in Brazil.


tuesday > Reboots As a Candidate Digital Toolkit That's a Bit Too Like launched with big ambitions and star appeal, hoping to crack the code on how to get millions of people to pool their political passions through their platform. When that ambition stalled, its founder Nathan Daschle--son of the former Senator--decided to pivot to offering political candidates an easy-to-use free web platform for organizing and fundraising. Now the new is out from stealth mode, entering a field already being served by competitors like NationBuilder, Salsa Labs and And strangely enough, seems to want its early users to ask for help. GO

Armenian Legislators: You Can Be As Anonymous on the 'Net As You Like—Until You Can't

A proposed bill in Armenia would make it illegal for media outlets to include defamatory remarks by anonymous or fake sources, and require sites to remove libelous comments within 12 hours unless they identify the author.


monday >

The Good Wife Looks for the Next Snowden and Outwits the NSA

Even as the real Edward Snowden faces questions over his motives in Russia, another side of his legacy played out for the over nine million viewers of last night's The Good Wife, which concluded its season long storyline exploring NSA surveillance. In the episode titled All Tapped Out, one young NSA worker's legal concerns lead him to becoming a whistle-blower, setting off a chain of events that allows the main character, lawyer Alicia Florrick (Julianna Margulies), and her husband, Illinois Governor Peter Florrick (Chris Noth), to turn the tables on the NSA using its own methods. GO

The Expanding Reach of China's Crowdsourced Environmental Monitoring Site, Danger Maps

Last week billionaire businessman Jack Ma, founder of the e-commerce company Alibaba, appealed to his “500 million-strong army” of consumers to help monitor water quality in China. Inexpensive testing kits sold through his company can be used to measure pH, phosphates, ammonia, and heavy metal levels, and then the data can be uploaded via smartphone to the environmental monitoring site Danger Maps. Although the initiative will push the Chinese authorities' tolerance for civic engagement and activism, Ethan Zuckerman has high hopes for “monitorial citizenship” in China.


The 13 Worst Bits of Russia's Current and Maybe Future Internet Legislation

It appears that Russia is on the brink of passing still more repressive Internet regulations. A new telecommunications bill that would require popular blogs—those with 3,000 or more visits a day—to join a government registry and conform to government-mandated standards is expected to pass this week. What follows is a list of the worst bits of both proposed and existing Russian Internet law. Let us know in the comments or on Twitter if we missed anything.


Transparency and Public Shaming: Pakistan Tackles Tax Evasion

In Pakistan, where only one in 200 citizens files their income tax return, authorities published a directory of taxpayers' details for the first time. Officials explained the decision as an attempt to shame defaulters into paying up.