Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

Romney's and Obama's Teams Take It To The Tweets

BY Sarah Lai Stirland | Friday, February 3 2012

Mitt Romney's campaign says President Obama is too focused on re-election. Picture: Courtesy Romney for President

The business of political fund-raising has taken a new turn this campaign season, with the latest twist seeing Barack Obama's re-election effort and Mitt Romney's pursuit of the Republican nomination each piggyback their latest fundraising pitch on the other's content, turning it around to appeal for money.

The two, dueling, hall-of-mirrors campaigns to motivate supporters to give money began last week. It started with an e-mail just after the president's State of the Union speech when Matt Rhoades, campaign manager for former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney, forwarded a fundraising e-mail from President Obama's campaign to the governor's own mailing list.

The e-mail's subject line: "If you liked what you saw." Obama for America's Campaign Manager Jim Messina sent out the note, which was a solicitation for a small donation of $3 from the president's supporters.

Rhoades had cheekily appropriated Messina's message, forwarded it and provided Romney's supporters with an alternative course of action if they didn't like what they saw: Give the $3 to Governor Romney instead.

And so began the latest round of tit-for-tat of stealing each others' lines, content and logos to point fingers at the other side while appealing to supporters for money.

"This is new: It's common to use others' words against them, that's Campaigning 101, but we haven't seen this level of integration before," said Ryan Cassin, a partner at Connect Strategic Communications, a Republican-leaning online strategy company based in Atlanta, Georgia.

And as Cassin notes, the strategy must be benefitting both campaigns, because they keep doing it. The whole idea is to use the tactic as a motivational tool for voters who are already invested in the campaigns in a game of one-upping each other.

The Obama team successfully deployed the tactic in the past couple of days when Messina fired off another fund-raising e-mail asking supporters for another $3 to help create its "Two-Term Fund." He was responding to the Romney's campaign's creation of its "One Term Fund," established to capitalize on the wave of Romney decisive Tuesday Republican primary victory against former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich in Florida.

The campaign reports that more then 52,529 people have donated more than two million dollars toward the "fund" as of Thursday afternoon, (when the page reporting the numbers was last updated.)

Meanwhile, Romney's campaign reports that it's raised $1.25 million so far for its own one-term fund.

Its fund-raising video on its solicitation page features camera shots of Obama's Facebook page, the campaign's web site, its Twitter page and its fund-raising e-mails as evidence that the president is more concerned about his re-election than on fixing the economy.

The back and forth isn't limited to e-mail. It's taking place on Twitter as well with both teams sending Tweets back and forth to each other reporting their fundraising numbers as they increased. That in turn inspired a Tweet from former George W. Bush White House Deputy Chief of Staff Karl Rove, who characterized the $3 fund-raising drive as a sign of "low enthusiasm," on the part of Obama supporters.

That Tweet made it into another Messina e-mail sent out this Friday morning that explained that the $3 amount is to get a wide group of people involved in the campaign instead of leaving it in the hands of "the guy doing a lot of the selling for a party bought and sold by special interests."

The Obama Two Term Fund's numbers speak for themselves. But some recipients of the e-mails seem fed up of the tactics.

"This is getting really childish," one Obama supporter commented to me.

But on Twitter, many supporters had the opposite reaction.

"@KarlRove @BarackObama Thanks Karl Troll. You just motivated me to donate a much larger amount to two term fund! 4 more years!!!" tweeted "markjacobs20" on Friday afternoon.

News Briefs

RSS Feed monday >

The Wisconsin Recall and the "Compas Effect"

Here and there in the run-up to the Wisconsin recall on June 5, we've noted the campaign of Lori Compas, a grassroots candidate who came from nowhere to challenge Republican State Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald for his seat. Her campaign went from a single Facebook post to petitions to trigger a recall against him to, finally, running to oppose him. Compas' unlikely campaign will come to a head Tuesday, and win or lose it has already triggered a growing bloom of insurgent campaigns in the Wisconsin recall, according to a new profile in Mother Jones. GO

The Instagram Filter As Design Aesthetic

The photos used in this Obama campaign get-out-the-vote site have a very Instagram vibe. If 2008 was the year of the Gotham font, maybe 2012 will be the year of the photo filter? GO

Obama 2012's Getting "Back to the We:" How's That Going? BuzzFeed Says Not So Well

Nobody disputes that the Obama campaign needs to use all the tools at its disposal to mobilize a grassroots base that is not as active and energized, or at least not yet, as it was in 2008. What's at issue is how effective the campaign has been so far in doing so — and we'll all find out by November, to be sure. GO

#PDF12: Announcing This Year's PDF Google Fellows

We're pleased to announce the following people have been named Google Fellows for Personal Democracy Forum 2012. Fifteen highly creative and talented people were selected out of a competitive pool of more than one hundred. Congrats to you all and see you next week at PDF12. They are: Joseph Agoada, international strategic communication ... GO

friday >

Cherokee Nation Members Start Online Effort Against Elizabeth Warren

Self-described members of the Cherokee Nation have begun an online effort critical of Democratic Senate candidate Elizabeth Warren's controversial claims of Native American heritage, as was first reported by The Republican in Springfield, Massachusetts. GO

Poetry of the Email Subject Line: Deadline Edition

There's something about a monthly fundraising deadline that brings out the romantic in our presidential campaign email subject line writers... GO

thursday >

California State Senate Moves Key Transparency Bills

The California State Senate approved on Thursday a couple of key transparency bills that will both help to make government documents more accessible online, and provide funding for the state's decrepit online finance disclosure system Cal-Access. GO

What to Make of "Twitchy," Michelle Malkin's Fan for Twitter Flames

The GOP new media machine tries to chase the spotlight anywhere it goes online, even going so far as to famously jump in on hashtags used by the White House or Obama campaign. It's just not clear what this exactly does for them. A case in point is Twitchy, a platform launched earlier this year by conservative commentator Michelle Malkin that picks out individual tweets to present on a website along with a few words of commentary. While it ventures into sports and culture news, its primary use seems to be to amplify the conservative hashtag wars, starting some fights and continuing others. GO

Obama Ad Targets Romney on Boston Globe Homepage

As various campaign officials pointed out on Twitter, the Obama campaign has bought a large ad criticizing Mitt Romney on the front of one of the Boston Globe's homepages, Boston.com. Apparently limited to Massachusetts-area web visitors, the ad proclaims that "Romney Economics didn't work for Massachusetts. It won't work for America." ... GO

wednesday >

California Controller John Chiang Hires Open Data Advocate And Tech Industry Outreach Director

California Controller John Chiang has hired open government advocate Tina Lee as the office's Bay Area director of outreach and innovation. GO

Democrats Create "Unlikeable" Romney Facebook Timeline for Video

The Democratic National Committee has released a video that constructs its own version of Mitt Romney's Facebook timeline. Using the motto "Little to Like," it's a "celebration" of Romney officially winning enough delegates for his nomination. GO

Transparency Advocates Frustrated With House Appropriators' Plan To Make A Plan

Open government advocates are up in arms over what appears to be another attempt by government bureaucrats to stall the move to enable bulk data downloads of legislative information online. GO

Open-Source Software for Governments in Spain

Two autonomous regions of Spain have recently made strides towards promoting open-source software for governmental use. GO

tuesday >

Twitter Hires a Director of Public Policy for Europe

Twitter has hired Sinéad McSweeney, director of communications for Garda Síochána, Ireland's national police service, as its director of public policy for Europe, according to Twitter's government account. McSweeney previously worked in the same role for the Police Service of Northern Ireland, and also served as special adviser to two attorneys general, David Byrne and Michael McDowell. She will be based in the company's office in Dublin. GO

More