Obama's "Online Townhall" Forum: Transparency Theater?

During last year's election, candidate Barack Obama staked out an expansive position on the ways that technology and the internet could be harnessed to open up the political process to ordinary citizens. And so far his administration has been delivering on many of his promises, most notably with projects like Data.gov, IT.Usaspending.gov and the Open Government Initiative, and potentially as well with the as-yet unfinished Recovery.gov site. Not only is the administration steadily making the federal government more transparent in its spending activities, it's beginning to involve the public directly in conceiving and drafting policy. Judging by their comments at this week's Personal Democracy Forum, and their work, like Vivek Kundra, Macon Phillips, and Beth Noveck seem quite comfortable trusting the "wisdom of crowds" and opening up the administration to approaches that trade some loss of control for a big increase in public participation.

But one element of his technology innovation agenda seems stuck in control mode: Obama's so-called "online townhalls." Yesterday's health care forum is a case in point. As far as I can tell, there was nothing about the collection of questions from participants online that made Obama's forum anything to get excited about. People were invited to submit questions via YouTube, Facebook and Twitter, but while this generated a lot of input--including a healthy number of video questions--so what?

Clinton's Digital Town Hall, Live from the DR

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is set to participate in a live "digital town hall," where she'll take questions submitted to her through Twitter, Facebook, and other means, while on a stop over in the Dominican Republic on her way to the Summit of the Americas in Trinidad and Tobago. The format's fairly similar to that of the Internet-powered "Open for Questions" town hall President Barack Obama held a few weeks back. That affair was, by general consensus, a bit stilted and forced. To see how Clinton handles the novel format, have a watch above.