- Clocking Ticking on Replacing "Campaign-Trail Charades" with Useful Debate
- How Do the Candidates Rate on Tech? You Decide
- Changes at Change.org: A Media Hub for Social Action
- Daily Digest: Why '08 Will Be the Election of Databases (One Way or Another)
- Last-Minute Push for Reluctant Technologists to Embrace, Evangelize Obama
- Daily Digest: From Field to Felonies to Fine-Tuned Targeting
- Must-Read: Zack Exley on the "New Organizers"
- The Curious Case of Palin's Inbox
- Public Submitted Thousands of Debate Questions Online, Not Millions [Updated]
- Daily Digest: Was Last Night a Waste of 90 Minutes? Debatable
By Nancy Scola, 08/09/2007 - 3:37pm
Here's something else that Hillary Clinton said at Yearly Kos, something that had nothing to do with lobbyists but was a similiar peek into her governing psyche. In her morning breakout session, Clinton warmed my little geek heart with her offhanded praise for the idea of electronic school records. It was a reminder that a true Tech President would see beyond just a free and open Internet to a fleshed-out vision of how hard a wired government and nation could rock.
As a question of policy, electronic school records have a lot going for it. A standardized format for education records would mean that American students could carry their school histories with them. That's a good thing for kids who move from school to school a lot, like immigrant and migrant children. And a truly smart school system could use that data to deliver a better educational product. They could track individual student performance, to see that Mary is quite good with numbers and should be pushed towards a math-heavy track. They could data mine in the aggregate, to see that while their freshmen and sophomores are flourishing in their science classes, those same students start to struggle in the science by the time they reach junior year.
Electronic school records avoid many of the problems that have plagued the implementation of electronic medical records. For one thing, the data in the average's student's school file is going to be less invasive than that in the average patient's medical record. Schools come with a federal driver for compliance that's lacking in the hodgepodge that is the American medical system, in the form of the Department of Education. And while it's somewhat scary to consider entrusting the records of all the nation's school-age children to a federal agency, can you think of a good reason that a system like this can't begin and end at developing a standardized format for records? Each kid's personalized information never has to travel beyond the walls of the school he's enrolled in or the school he hopes to get into. For the system to pass civil liberties muster, the kid (or rather, her parents) would need to own the data. That part's important.
(The "tracking chip" mentioned in the title of this post is, I hope, an obvious exaggeration. Nobody would want that, except maybe...nevermind -- this is a blessedly non-partisan blog.)
With the caveat that I've been thinking through the policy implications of electronic school records for all of about a day and a half, my first read is that it's a clever use of technology that (a) is doable and (b) would actually make the lives of Americans demonstrably better than they were before.
But the point isn't that it's a good policy. It might, in final analysis, be a dumb idea. But the point is that it's bold thinking firmly rooted in an understanding of how technology can be a force for concrete, tangible good. And in my mind, if you're a presidential candidate today, I can't believe that yours will be a Tech Presidency if you don't start to demonstrate soon that you get the power of tech down to your bones.
more from Nancy Scola's blog | login or register to post comments
Recent blog posts
Recent comments
- Re:
14 hours 36 min ago - RE: The Curious Case of Palin's Inbox
23 hours 4 min ago - Thanks, Micah
2 days 9 min ago - Fascinating on many levels ...
4 days 10 hours ago - But the Eagles of Death Metal...
5 days 5 hours ago - A first try at an election protection tagging taxonomy
5 days 6 hours ago - Case study
5 days 6 hours ago - This could be a great case study ...
5 days 6 hours ago - Now's the Time to Act
5 days 15 hours ago - Re: Interference
5 days 20 hours ago
Most Emailed
- Daily Digest: Why '08 Will Be the Election of Databases (One Way or Another)
- Last-Minute Push for Reluctant Technologists to Embrace, Evangelize Obama
- Must-Read: Zack Exley on the "New Organizers"
- Thoughts on How to Respond when Huckabee Spreads False Emails
- Twitter: An Antidote to Election Day Voting Problems?

print
email
delicious
digg
technorati
Your cruel!
{The "tracking chip" mentioned in the title of this post is, I hope, an obvious exaggeration. Nobody would want that, except maybe...nevermind -- this is a blessedly non-partisan blog.)
UGH AND I FELL FOR IT!