Personal Democracy Plus Our premium content network. LEARN MORE You are not logged in. LOG IN NOW >

Lies, Damn Lies, and Two Million on the Mall

BY Nancy Scola | Tuesday, September 15 2009

For whatever reason, this random bit of recently-aquired political trivia keeps coming to mind today: when Romanian dictator and all-around murderous bully Nicolae Ceausescu got tired of attending rallies and other political events, he'd simply have his photo clumsily slapped onto a picture of the event and pass it out to the newspapers, who would dutifully reprint the thing as sacred truth. But they didn't have Photoshop back then, and the mock-ups were so clumsily done that nobody inside or outside Romania actually fell for Ceausescu's fraud. Sometimes it's difficult to figure out what has happened at political events. And we've been fighting about how crowd estimates probably since people were retelling the story of how Caesar got killed the day after it went down. That said, there are those times where the only sensible response is to scratch your head and say to yourself, "Now, something about that that doesn't look quite right."

Alas, that scratching of the ol' head didn't happen all that much this weekend, as misinformation spread like wildfire about the crowd gathered for the 9/12 Taxpayer Rally took place down on the National Mall. In the mess, tweets were treated as sacred truth. That's bad for all of us who still believe that there sometimes exists objective fact. And it is also, arguably, bad for conservatives who hoped to use this weekend's rally as a demonstration of the momentum of their burgeoning movement.

That there is anger about the policies, politics, personalities, and power of Barack Obama and Democratic Congress is a given. But getting a handle on how widespread that disapproving sentiment is, and where it is coming from, is a much tougher question to make sense of -- and may well be the defining political question of this fall as the health care debate heats back up in Congress and the impact of the trillions of dollars in government spending of the last several months becomes clearer. So it was of little surprise that how many people were filling the National Mall and surrounding streets became a hot political question. There were a lot of people there, no doubt. In fact, the D.C. Fire Department put out an estimate of 60,000 to 70,000, which is nothing for organizers to be embarrassed about. But two million is a tremendous number of people, and a figure like that should make you stop and pause before passing it around. The notion, though, spread unchecked through conservative blogs like Jawa Report and Riehl World View and Pajamas Media's Roger Simon, as well as Twitter, that the crowd assembled in Washington had indeed swelled to two million people -- an estimate that, as Five Thirty Eight's Nate Silver points off, was only off from the city estimate of the crowd by a factor of about 30.

To borrow an instant classic from the New York Times Bob Mackey in the context of the swirling of information around post-elections Iran, "Re-tweeting is a kind of reporting." And the "reporting" when it came to estimated the crowds at the 9/12 rally was distincting, well, miserable. Really, really bad. Media Matter's Eric Boehlert tracks the anatomy of how the two million rumor spread, with conservative blogger Michelle Malkin playing a staring role. Malkin added the enormous amplification of her considerable pulpit by posting that juicy two million nugget first posted by a tweeter by the name of Tabitha Hale, proprietor, it seems, of the Pink Elephant Pundit.com blog. Malkin added the commentary "Teeny, tiny fringe, huh?" (Malkin has since updated her report with a correction.)

Hale, it seems, picked up and pumped up a bit a number from the President of FreedomWorks, one of the organizers of the event. FreedomWork's Matt Kibbe had gone on the stage at the rally to report to the crowd that ABC News was talking about a crowd size of one million to 1.5 million people. Nuh-uh, said ABC News. The news organization took the unusual step of offering the meta-commentary that it hadn't in the least reported a number that huge. For his part, Kibee explained away his role in the dissemination of bad information by saying that, "with a dead iPhone," he had picked up the bad number from "tweets from a number of different folks behind the stage citing the ABC estimate."

At some point, of course, you can go down the rabbit hole of where these "different folks" cited by Kibbe got their information, if not from his falsely reporting to the assembled crowd the ABC estimate. But where the rumor got its start isn't as nearly as important as the way in which it spread, unchecked, like some really aggressive virus.

For more commentary, check out the Columbia Journalism Review's Megan Garber, who somewhat bombastically frames the mess as a testament to conservatives' loose grasp of facts. Oh, and that photo up top, the one passed all around conservative blogs as photographic proof of how big the crowd grew? The St. Petersburg Times' PolitiFact says it wasn't taken Saturday at all. It's from the 1997 Promise Keepers rally. Now that was a crowd.

News Briefs

RSS Feed today >

What German Politicians Think of Google Glass

The German government led by Chancellor Angela Merkel has not had the easiest relationship with Google. The company launched a public campaign against a law backed by her coalition that would require search engines to pay to show news articles in search results, with mixed results. What's more, Google has long had to navigate the privacy waters in Germany and throughout the European Union. But that has not stopped her federal minister for economics and technology, Philipp Rösler, from giving Google Glass an enthusiastic test run as he leads a delegation of German technology companies and politicians on a trip to Silicon Valley this week as part of German Valley Week. GO

Crowdsourcing Waste Management Solutions in Montenegro

For once we aren't talking about the worldwide scarcity of toilets, just good old-fashioned household waste. Montenegro has a garbage problem so bad even the tourists are complaining about it. A new mobile app sponsored by the Agency for Environmental Protection, NGO Ozon and United Nations Development Programme in Montenegro will hopefully get citizens involved in reporting illegal garbage dumps. GO

monday >

Her Majesty's Government Wants to Monetize Open Data

A new paper from the chair of the U.K. government's Open Strategy Board outlines the best practices for the government's open data policies. The government-commissioned Shakespeare Review – after author Stephan Shakespeare – looks into ways to monetize open data, and recommends an all-encompassing National Data Strategy.

GO

Will Silicon Valley "Disrupt" Politics With a Candidate for Congress?

Sean Parker, of Napster fame and now executive general partner at venture capital firm Founders Fund, has invested in political startups before. But last week, he went a step further — co-hosting a fundraising event for a candidate for Congress. Parker and SV Angel co-founder Ron Conway organized a crowd of Internet industry luminaries to support Ro Khanna, a former assistant deputy secretary in Barack Obama's Commerce Department. Khanna is preparing a challenge to Rep. Mike Honda (D-Calif.), whose newly redrawn congressional district encompasses Silicon Valley. GO

Burma's Upcoming Telecom Revolution Will Probably Not Bring Internet Freedom

Burma (Myanmar) is on the threshold of an Internet revolution, but Human Rights Watch has warned companies to proceed with caution or risk trampling Burmese citizens' rights. GO

friday >

Chilean Anti-Corruption Resource: A Crowdsourced Database of Social and Political Connections

In countries where a small minority of social circles have a majority of the political and economic power, personal relationships can affect major decision-making, a serious concern of anti-corruption activists. A new web platform stores personal profiles of key players in Chilean business and politics, complete with biographies and personal and professional connections through family, education, social circles, employers and coworkers, to make tracking social relationships and conflict-of-interest easier. Called Poderopedia (from the Spanish word for power), the project sounds kind of like LinkedIn, but the creation and management of profiles is being crowdsourced out to journalists, activists and concerned citizens.

GO

Middle Eastern Telecom Accused of Working With Saudi Arabia to Spy on Citizens

Mobily, an arm of the state-owned Middle Eastern telecom giant Etihad Etisalat, has been accused of working with Saudi Arabia to develop software that would allow the government to bypass protections for social media users. The exposé comes from Moxie Marlinspike (neé Matthew Rosenfield), an expert in a certain type of malicious Internet attack called MITM (man-in-the-middle), whereby attackers intercept and secretly alter private messages exchanged via email and other social media platforms. GO

Saudi Religious Leader Warns Twitter Users of Consequences in the Afterlife

In late March, Saudi Arabia's top religious cleric said Twitter was for clowns and corrupters. Earlier this week, he said anyone using social media, in particular Twitter, “has lost this world and the afterlife.” His comments might be laughable, if they did not come at a time when the Saudi government is looking into monitoring or blocking social media sites and eliminating user anonymity.

GO

thursday >

What The Other Silicon Valley Immigration Group Is Doing This Month

A bipartisan coalition of political advocacy, business and tech groups are moving ahead to launch a social media blitz next week designed to persuade members of the Senate to vote in favor of immigration reform legislation supported in Silicon Valley. "We're going to create a virtual digital storm," said Jeremy Robbins in a Wednesday ... GO

The New Yorker Hopes "Strongbox" Is a Wiretap-Proof Sieve for Leaks

The New Yorker yesterday became the first outlet to implement DeadDrop, a new system for sources to submit information to journalists online in a more secure and anonymous way than, for example, email. GO

Female Organizer of Pakistan's First Hackathon Stresses Collaboration Over Competition

After Pakistan banned Valentine's Day this year, Sabeen Mahmud started an online protest in which people uploaded photos to mock the government ban. In the weeks following she received death threats and menacing phone calls, and early on she had to stay home from work. That did nothing, however, to keep her from further organizing. Last month, the café she started in Karachi hosted Pakistan's first ever hackathon, which tackled problems including sanitation, crime, disaster management, and education. She even invited a government representative to observe the initial conversations, tackling sensitive areas like government inefficiency and elections.

GO

wednesday >

White House Innovation Fellows Project Spins Off Into A Business

Clay Johnson and Adam Becker joined the Presidential Innovation Fellows program to help the White House fix the way government does business. Now they're turning that mission into a business themselves. GO

Fighting Fires With Data, New York City Launches New Safety Inspection System

Mayor Michael Bloomberg announced today that New York City has implemented city-wide a new risk based inspection system focused on fire safety that is driven by analytics from multiple city agencies. GO

Chinese Netizens Use Digital Initiative to Gain Media Attention for Unsolved Poisoning Case

Last month a medical science student at a Shanghai university died from poisoning, allegedly murdered by his roommate. The specifics of the crime echoed a case from the mid-1990s, in which a 19-year-old student was poisoned with thallium. That case has once again been thrown into the media spotlight, but after 18 years the media has changed and the spotlight means a trending hashtag on Sina Weibo or an online petition to the U.S. President.

GO

PDF France 2013: “Au Code, Citoyens!”

This year PDF France will take place in Paris on June 13, with the theme "Au Code, Citoyens!" ("To Code, Citizens!") The speakers' lineup includes some of the continent's leaders in the digital revolution. GO

tuesday >

Website Imitation is Flattery in New York City Council Race

A New York City Council candidate who had made his name as a technology consultant and spearheaded an open government initiative several years ago found parts of his website copied by another City Council candidate in a different borough, as Politicker first reported. GO

More