The Audacity to Ask a Question

It's not every morning that you run into one of the most powerful men in the country in relatively intimate and unguarded surroundings, so today as I was boarding the shuttle down to DC and saw White House senior advisor David Axelrod seated by a window just behind the first class section, I decided I had to seize the moment. My parents gave me "change the world" disease when I was young, after all, and I probably will never shake it.

The aisle was full in front of me anyway and thus I was literally standing across from him. Knowing I might only have a minute, I quickly pondered what to say.

"Is this 'change we can believe in'?" I asked. He didn't respond at first so I repeated the question to make clear I was talking to him. It was his slogan, after all, that he and the rest of the Obama '08 campaign, had offered to the nation.

Axelrod looked up calmly, peering at me over the glasses perched on the bridge of his nose. What are you referring to, he asked.

Jeez, there wasn't really time to properly answer that. I decided to keep it simple, rather than try to explain why I think Obama isnt doing enough to change how DC works. Keeping my voice as friendly as possible, I said, "The health care bill. It's so watered down with compromises."

"We're just trying to get the bill to conference," he responded. And it wasn't clear what would be in the final bill, he added. I looked at him skeptically.

"Do you have health insurance?" he asked me. Yes, I said, a bit nonplussed. "Well, we're trying to get coverage to the millions of people who don't," he said. (It struck me later that perhaps he thought I, a 40-something white man, was perhaps not an Obama voter.)

Don't get me wrong, I said. I want that too. But I wish you'd "be less poll-driven and lead the country." (Morgan Freeman's performance as Nelson Mandela in Invictus was on my mind, having seen it Saturday night. Go see it and you'll know what I'm referring to.)

He looked like he wanted to argue the point, but by now two air marshals -- one seated in the aisle near Axelrod and one who had gotten up from the row behind him to stand near me, were looking a bit unhappy. I decided it was time to find my seat. "Good luck," I wished him, and walked away.

Featured: 

Comments

Well done, Micah

You did exactly what I would have wanted to do but wouldn't have thought of in the moment.

--
personal blog: http://lotusmedia.org
local issues: http://OrangePolitics.org

Well done

It's terribly important that whenever these people venture outside the bubble that they have to deal with ordinary people's questions and opinions. They forget and since this one designs the polling, he's particularly likely to believe what his own frames elicit. Consultants don't like being made aware of the amount of art that is interlaced with their science. If he isn't polling to find out whether people think his guy is flunking leadership, he probably doesn't know how widespread that sentiment is.

Can it happen here?

my new theory of change

"Nothing changes until the consultants change."

Nice one, Micah. No idea what I would've asked him, probably some lame question about data. At least that probably wouldn't have gotten the air marshall's kinckers in a twist.

The Audacity to Ask a Question

When Mandela left office after 5 years, he had not delivered on what he promised because of circumstances beyond his control. In fact, to this day, those promises have not been kept. The biggest lesson from Invictus was finding an area where left and right could find common ground - rugby. Hence the comparison with HCR and Invictus is shallow at best.

See also:
Hollywood gets it wrong over Nelson Mandela and Francois Pienaar
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/rugbyunion/news/6796296/Hollywood-gets-...